​Leatherman sells $40-$300 multi-tools you're supposed to hand down to your kids.

So why does their popup treat visitors like bargain hunters looking for 20% off?

They've been around since 1983, building pliers-based multi-tools in Portland, Oregon.

Their tools aren't cheap.

And they're not supposed to be—these are tools backed by a 25-year warranty (40 years if you're in their Insider program).

But when I hit their site ready to learn more, their popup made them look like a brand competing on price—not quality.

Here's what popped up:

•••

Problem 1: Generic "news and offers" hook for a considered purchase

"Sign up for Leatherman news and offers."

That's not a value proposition. That's a corporate email subject line from 2009.

When someone's considering a $150 multi-tool, they don't care about "news."

They care about making the right choice.

Which tool fits their needs?

Will it end up in their junk drawer after two months?

Are they wasting money on features they'll never use?

Those are the real questions running through their head.

Here's how I'd fix it:

Headline: "Buying your first quality multi-tool?"

Offer: Free 5-day crash course: "The Multi-Tool Buyer's Guide" - Everything you need to know so you don't end up with a $150 Leatherman collecting dust in your glovebox, 14 tools you'll never use while missing the 2 you actually need, and going back to your $8 gas station knife because "it's easier" (even if you've watched every unboxing video on YouTube).

The original attracts bargain shoppers just hunting for 20% off codes they'll use once.

The fixed version attracts someone researching their first serious multi-tool purchase who'll spend $150+ without blinking if they're confident it's the right choice.

•••

Problem 2: Asking for first name before trust

They're asking for your first name AND email address before you've even scrolled past the homepage hero section.

Why does a tool company need your first name to send you "exclusive offers and more"?

They don't.

But asking for it creates friction.

Every extra field is another reason for someone to close the popup and keep browsing.

And the timing makes it worse.

10 seconds after landing. That's barely enough time to read "Multi-Tools, Knives, and Pocket Tools" in the header.

Here's how I'd fix it:

Email only. No first name field.

And switch to exit-intent or 60+ second scroll depth so people actually have time to explore before getting interrupted.

•••

Problem 3: Wall of legal text killing mobile conversions

On mobile, this popup is dominated by privacy policy language.

The entire middle section is fine print about "personalized marketing emails" and "data processing."

It's longer than the actual offer.

Your eyes glaze over. And even if you wanted to read it, the popup reads like terms and conditions instead of a helpful resource.

Here's how I'd fix it:

Move the legal language to a small "Privacy Policy" link below the email input.

Keep the popup focused on the value—what they're getting, not what you're allowed to do with their data.

On desktop, the popup works fine.

On mobile, it's 60% legal disclaimer and 40% actual offer.

That's a conversion killer.

•••

Problem 4: "Subscribe" button for people who don't want emails

The CTA button says "SUBSCRIBE."

But these aren't people trying to subscribe to a newsletter.

They're trying to figure out which multi-tool to buy.

They're researching.

They're comparing options.

They're looking for guidance.

"Subscribe" makes it sound like they're signing up for promotional emails.

Which is exactly what they're trying to avoid.

Here's how I'd fix it:

"Send Me Day 1" or "Start the Guide".

Make the button about receiving value, not committing to a subscription.

•••

Here's my fixed popup:

What makes this version better?

Better timing

It gives people time to understand the product.

Exit-intent or scroll-depth triggers mean they've already spent time exploring the site.

They're more informed about what Leatherman offers and more likely to engage with an educational resource.

Pain-first messaging

The offer targets real problems tool buyers have.

For example, a $150 tool might just gather dust in your glovebox.

You may pick 14 tools you won’t use, missing the 2 you need every day.

Or, you might grab that cheap gas station knife instead of the pricey one that stays unused.

It’s not about generic "news and offers.""

Objection handling

Adding "even if you've watched every unboxing video on YouTube" helps disarm skeptics.

It shows you understand their doubts.

Watching reviews alone doesn’t mean you’ll know which tool suits your needs.

Zero friction

Email only.

No first name requirement.

No wall of privacy text on mobile.

You can ask about their name and preferences after you've earned trust through the first email.

Education that builds conviction

• Day 1 explains the 3 most important things to know before buying—like why price doesn't equal features and which 3-5 tools you'll actually use 90% of the time.
  ​
• Day 2 covers the 3 biggest mistakes people make, like buying based on "cool factor" instead of actual daily use.
  ​
• Day 3 walks through choosing the right tool by mapping your real tasks.
  ​
• By Day 5, they understand exactly which Leatherman model fits their workflow and why the warranty matters.

Here's a quick before-and-after comparison to show the differences:

•••

Leatherman's final score: 19/54 points

That's a 35%.

Not exactly something you'd frame and hang on the wall.

They're leaving serious money in potential conversions on the table.

Most of the lost points came from their generic headline/offer strategy and their mobile experience dominated by legal text.

If you're selling premium products ($40-$300), your popup should educate and qualify, not interrupt and collect names.

Lead with expertise, not "exclusive offers."

OK, that's it for today.

Until next time, see ya!

Gannon

P.S. If you want me to break down YOUR popup strategy in a future newsletter (like I just did with Leatherman), hit reply with your website URL.

I'm looking for 2-3 DTC tech/accessory brands to feature next month.

Fair warning: I'll be brutally honest about what's broken and exactly how to fix it.

But if you're cool with that and want to see where your popup lands on the 54-point scale, send me your link.

And if you'd rather audit it yourself first? Grab the kit here.